Picture yourself with a supplier’s contract open and an approval email half written. The demonstration was impressive. You can already imagine the problem disappearing. Then a reference mentions an implementation that took much longer than expected.
Almost immediately, you have an explanation. That customer was different. Their team was “probably” less prepared. Your situation is simpler.
Each explanation could be reasonable. What deserves attention is the speed with which an awkward detail becomes another reason to proceed.
The preference gets there first
In The Divided Brain, I explain human behaviour through two interconnected gears: the Old Brain and the New Brain. The large, automatic gear is the Old Brain, which makes fast emotional appraisals. It responds to rewards, familiarity, safety and social standing. The smaller New Brain gear gives us language, reasoning and deliberate reflection.
Those automatic tendencies helped our ancestors survive and flourish. Recognizing an opportunity quickly, conserving effort and staying accepted by the group had practical value. In a modern business, however, a reassuring demonstration and a confident salesperson can earn our enthusiasm long before we have examined an implementation plan.
The New Brain can then explain the preference rather than examine it. In the book, I discuss special pleading and Jonathan Haidt’s press secretary analogy: we produce a convincing account of a choice that already feels right.
The same New Brain can also press the clutch, interrupt the automatic momentum and inspect how we arrived at the decision. That is metacognition: thinking about our thinking. The important distinction is between building a defence and conducting a check.
Intelligence can supply more reasons
Being smart doesn’t make us immune to talking ourselves into something. It can make us very good at arguing for what we already wanted.
In their 2012 paper, [Richard West, Russell Meserve and Keith Stanovich](https://www.keithstanovich.com/Site/Research_on_Reasoning_files/West_Stanovich_JPSP2012.pdf) studied the bias blind spot: recognising thinking biases more readily in others than in ourselves. Measures of cognitive sophistication did not reduce the blind spots they examined; higher cognitive ability was, if anything, associated with a larger blind spot.
A related distinction appears in work by David Perkins and colleagues, discussed in [Stanovich, West and Toplak’s 2013 review](https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721413480174). Intelligence was related to generating more arguments overall, but much less related to generating arguments against one’s own position.
Having more reasons available does not mean the uncomfortable reasons received equal attention. That is a useful distinction when a purchase recommendation looks thorough because it contains several pages of advantages and one brisk paragraph dismissing the risks.
Give the original concern a fair hearing
Return to the supplier’s contract. Before signing, write down the concern you have been quickest to explain away. Keep it specific. An implementation taking longer than promised is something to investigate. A vague instruction to be more objective gives you very little to do.
Give someone who has no stake in this supplier the original reference or estimate. Let them see what was actually said, rather than only the reassuring summary you have already prepared.
Ask them to identify the condition that would make signing a bad idea. Perhaps the supplier’s approach depends on staff time you do not have. Perhaps the promised integration has not been demonstrated with your existing systems. Establish which concern could change the decision, then check it.
For example, the next step might be a conversation with the reference about what caused the delay. If the cause applies to your team, it belongs in your decision. If it doesn’t, you have a reason to proceed that rests on an investigated difference rather than an assumed one.
Leave room for an answer you dislike
The difficult part is allowing the check to matter. It is easy to request a second opinion while supplying enough persuasive context to make agreement feel like the helpful response.
State the attraction openly. You liked the demonstration. You want the problem solved. You would prefer to sign this week. Then separate those preferences from the condition you need to verify.
You may still choose the supplier. You may negotiate a smaller first commitment or decide that the implementation risk is manageable. You may also discover that the promise depends on something nobody has checked.
Each is a more useful outcome before a signature than after one. The aim is to give the awkward detail enough room to affect what happens next.
Know when to stop checking
Use this pause for consequential commitments, especially choices that are costly or difficult to undo. You do not need a review committee for every ordinary purchase.
Define the concern, decide what evidence would resolve it and give the check an endpoint. Once the relevant condition has been examined, make the decision with the uncertainty that remains. Otherwise, reflection can become another way to avoid committing.
Enthusiasm tells you something about what you value. Keep it in the conversation. Before sending the approval email, make sure the concern you least wanted to hear has been allowed into the conversation too.
Paul Larche is the author of The Divided Brain (CanReads 2026 Business/Marketing Winner | BookLife Prize 2025 Semifinalist, 10/10 Score, Editor’s Pick).