Why Smart People Make Irrational Decisions at Work

Short answer: Smart people make irrational decisions at work because intelligence does not remove emotional reactions, social pressures or cognitive biases. In The Divided Brain, Paul Larche explains how the Old Brain can favour what feels safe or familiar, while the New Brain supplies convincing reasons. Better judgment starts with noticing that sequence.

Doesn’t intelligence protect us from irrational decisions?

Intelligence helps us solve problems. It also helps us defend conclusions we have already reached. Those are different uses of the same ability.

In my book, I describe the mind as two interlocked gears. The Old Brain is the larger gear: fast, automatic, emotional, shaped by instinct and learned intuition. The New Brain is the smaller gear: capable of language, reasoning, imagination and deliberate reflection. This is a practical metaphor, not a literal division into two separate brains.

By default, the New Brain can act like a press secretary, explaining why the Old Brain’s choice was sensible. We experience the explanation as careful thinking, even when it is a defence of our first reaction.

Being articulate does not tell us which job our reasoning is doing. We have to ask whether we are examining a decision or simply making it sound better.

Why can workplace decisions feel so personal?

Work involves more than tasks and targets. It involves income, reputation, influence and membership in a group. A proposal can make business sense and still feel personally threatening.

The evolutionary perspective in The Divided Brain matters here. Quick threat detection, familiarity and loyalty to a group helped our ancestors survive and flourish. These tendencies were useful long before anyone had a quarterly budget to defend.

Modern work puts that old equipment in unfamiliar conditions. We face information overload and complex choices, while a disagreement can still feel like a threat to status or belonging. Rejecting a colleague’s idea may feel safer than admitting our own plan needs to change.

That is an explanatory lens, not permission to diagnose someone’s motives. Resistance may reflect a real risk we have missed. Leaders need to understand the concern before deciding that another presentation full of facts will resolve it.

What do cognitive biases look like in a meeting?

The book describes several patterns that translate readily into workplace decisions. Recognizing the pattern gives us a useful question to ask, not a label to attach to a colleague.

Confirmation bias means favouring evidence that supports an existing view and discounting evidence that challenges it. In a decision discussion, the warning sign is applying a tougher standard to inconvenient information than to information we like.

Sunk cost bias means continuing because of time, money or effort already spent. The useful question is whether the next investment makes sense from here, rather than whether stopping would make the earlier investment feel wasted.

Social proof means looking to other people for guidance, especially under uncertainty. Agreement can be informative, but a room full of agreement does not settle whether the proposal is sound.

All three can make a choice feel reasonable while pulling attention away from the decision we actually need to make.

What does pressing the clutch look like in practice?

In Chapter 5 of The Divided Brain, I describe a business crisis that brought this home. A partner in a Kitchener radio station triggered a shotgun clause. I had thirty days to find eight million dollars or walk away. I did not have the money and could not borrow it.

Sitting in a coffee shop, my first response was panic. The ending seemed decided before I had examined my options.

Then I took out a napkin and began mapping the worst-case outcomes, the resources I still had and what I could do next. The situation had not changed. My way of approaching it had.

That is what I mean by pressing the clutch: interrupting an automatic reaction and engaging the New Brain deliberately. The napkin did not solve the whole problem. It gave me a way to think beyond the outcome I feared.

How can leaders help teams make better decisions?

Telling people to be more rational is unlikely to help if the conversation itself makes them defensive. A leader can start by acknowledging what is at stake, including the human concerns, then making room to examine the evidence.

That is not an invitation to replace facts with reassurance. Emotion gives a decision meaning; evidence helps us assess whether the proposed action deserves support. Both belong in the conversation.

Metacognition, or thinking about our own thinking, is the practical skill behind the clutch. It means noticing a reaction, questioning the assumptions underneath it and considering another explanation before committing.

Leaders can model that openly. Saying that new information has changed your assessment gives the team an example of what updating a judgment looks like. The aim is not endless hesitation. It is to use deliberate attention where an automatic answer could be costly.

A Monday-morning clutch check

Use these four prompts before an important decision:

  1. Name the reaction. What feels threatening, attractive or familiar? Acknowledge the feeling without treating it as proof.
  2. Separate observation from interpretation. Write down what you actually know, then the explanation you have added. Look for assumptions hiding between the two.
  3. Test the preferred answer. What evidence would make you reconsider? Apply the same standard to information that supports your position and information that challenges it.
  4. Consider another route. Map an alternative and assess the next step on its merits. Do not let money already spent make the decision for you.

These are workplace applications of the book’s metacognition and bias checks, not a promise of perfect judgment. A pause is useful only if we use it to examine something.

How is this different from Thinking, Fast and Slow?

Daniel Kahneman’s Thinking, Fast and Slow describes fast, automatic thinking and slower, effortful reasoning through System 1 and System 2. It is one of the explanatory anchors I discuss in The Divided Brain.

My Old Brain and New Brain gears give leaders and communicators a visual way to work with related decision dynamics. The gears emphasize how emotional reactions and the stories we tell about them interact, and how metacognition lets us reconsider an initial response.

The models are related, not identical anatomical descriptions. Neither should become a rule that intuition is always wrong or slower thinking always produces the right answer.

For the branding and leadership application, see The Divided Brain vs Thinking, Fast and Slow. The useful question is how we bring feeling, reflection and evidence into the decision together.

Bring this conversation to your organization

This is the subject of my keynote, Why Smart People Make Irrational Decisions. Drawing from The Divided Brain, it helps audiences recognize automatic assumptions, understand why facts alone can fail to persuade and practise a more deliberate response.

Formats include a conference keynote, a leadership session and an interactive workshop. Explore the keynote and formats for your team, association or conference.

We will not stop having first reactions. We can get better at noticing when we have started defending one instead of examining it.

Paul Larche is the author of The Divided Brain (CanReads 2026 Business/Marketing Winner | BookLife Prize 2025 Semifinalist, 10/10 Score, Editor’s Pick).